Reinan Law
  • Our Firm
  • Areas of Practice
    • Abuse, Neglect & Wrongful Death of the Elderly & Disabled
    • Mental Health & Addiction Rehabilitation Neglect & Abuse
    • Healthcare Attorney – Consumer Protection in Healthcare
    • Bedsore Lawyer in Colorado
  • FAQs
  • Blog
  • Recent Cases
  • Contact Us
  • Locations
    • Minnesota
    • Wyoming
 
 (303) 894-0383
July 29 2011

Law Offices of JM Reinan Appealing District of Colorado’s Dismissal of Civil Rights Law Suit Brought Against County Run Nursing Home

The Law Offices of J.M. Reinan, P.C. is appealing to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit the dismissal of a lawsuit brought on behalf of a former Bent County Healthcare Center resident, Alice Hawkins.

 

The lawsuit was brought against Bent County and the Administrator of the Bent County Healthcare Center, and alleged violations of the Federal Nursing Home Reform Act of 1987 (FNHRA).

 

Alice Hawkins was admitted to Bent County Healthcare Center with a pressure sore she had developed while at Parkview Hospital.  The suit alleged that Bent County Healthcare Center improperly admitted Ms. Hawkins and then, once admitted, violated several federal statutory requirements concerning Ms. Hawkins’s care, including requirements governing pressure sore treatment, proper nutrition and hydration, communications with physicians and family members, and facility administration. Ms. Hawkins alleged that as a result of these statutory violations, she was discharged from Bent County Healthcare Center with a serious and life-threatening pressure sore that required surgery and removal of a portion of her tailbone.

 

Ms. Hawkins claimed that Bent County Healthcare Center violated her federal statutory rights by “failing to satisfy the standards of quality of care and resident rights set forth in 42 U.S.C. §§ 1395i-3 and 1396r.”  The suit was brought under the theory that these and other violations of the specific provisions of the FNHRA provided Ms. Hawkins with a private right of action to pursue a civil rights case under 42 U.S.C. § 1983.

 

Bent County and its Administrator moved to dismiss the case arguing that the FNHRA does not create an enforceable private right of action under 42 U.S.C. § 1983.

 

The court granted the motion to dismiss stating that, “even when a statute speaks in terms of rights, there is no presumption of enforceability.”  The Court further found that “FNHRA provisions focus on what state nursing facilities must do to maintain funding, not on the benefits received by the residents.”

 

In its ruling, the District Court expressed disagreement with the Third Circuit Court’s decision in Grammar v. John J. Kane Regional Centers-Glenn Hazel, 570 F.3d 520 (3rd Cir. 2009).  In Grammar, the Third Circuit held that the FNHRA does create an enforceable private right of action under § 1983.

 

This issue had not yet been addressed in the District of Colorado, and has not yet been addressed by the Tenth Circuit.  Courts in other jurisdictions have held that the FNHRA does create an enforceable private right of action under § 1983.

 

The Federal Rights Project at the National Senior Citizens Law Center will be filing an amicus brief in support of the Reinan Law Office’s appeal.

Sister of Former Assisted Living Facility Resident Brings Suit for Fraud, Deceptive Trade Practices CMHIP Security Break Brain Injured Patient’s Arm Then Deny Him Medical Treatment

Related Posts

Nursing Home Abuse & Neglect - Reinan Law

Blog

Mishandling of Sexual Assault Claim for 77-year-old Woman

Domestic violence

Blog

How to Report Elder Abuse in Colorado

Law and Justice concept. Mallet of the judge, books, scales of justice.

Blog, Recent Cases

Reinan Law Wins $3.6 Million Jury Verdict Against Colorado Assisted Living Facility

LAW OFFICES OF J.M. REINAN, P.C.

Since 1999, The Law Offices of J. M. Reinan has been dedicated to cases involving nursing home abuse, medical malpractice, elder law, negligence resulting in injury or death, consumer protection, civil rights violations, and outrageous conduct. We are fully licensed and practice in Colorado, Minnesota, and Wyoming. If you feel your case could benefit from our representation, contact us today for a consultation!

We’re located at:
1437 North High Street 
Denver, CO 80218
Phone: (303) 894-0383
Fax: (303) 894-0384

680 South Cache Street, Ste. 100
Jackson, WY 83001
Phone: (307) 249-4900

333 Washington Avenue North, Ste. 300
Minneapolis, MN 55401
Phone: (612) 888-5290

info@reinanlaw.com

 

LATEST BLOG POSTS

  • Mishandling of Sexual Assault Claim for 77-year-old Woman
  • How to Report Elder Abuse in Colorado
  • Reinan Law Wins $3.6 Million Jury Verdict Against Colorado Assisted Living Facility

RECENT CASES

  • Ruling of Johnson v. Rowan
  • Law Offices of J.M. Reinan Files Racketeering Lawsuits Against Clear View Behavioral Health Center
  • Reinan Law Wins $3.6 Million Jury Verdict Against Colorado Assisted Living Facility

Contact Us for a Consultation





Contact Us for a Consultation

Copyright © 2019 Law Offices of J.M. Reinan, P.C. All rights reserved.
Terms of Use Resources & Articles XML Sitemap HTML SItemap